Halloween Avatars!

Hi Everyone!  With the holidays coming, I wanted to switch avatars for my Etsy account.  My usual avatar (which you can see on the left side of the page) is a picture of my now-famous cat Gizmo.  He doesn't sit well for pictures, so I photoshopped a necklace on him since he won't wear one in real life. 

I created my Christmas avatar (him with a santa hat on), but as my mother says, "Isn't it a bit early for Christmas?  Whatever happened to Halloween?"  I thought of that, but I also thought it a bit late for a Halloween avatar.

But she put the idea in my head so I had to do it!  Now I've made two, and can't decide which one is better:

The Ghostly Gizmo





or

The Giz-O-Lantern?







What do you think?